A recent study has found that cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia delivered by telemedicine is as effective as face-to-face delivery.
Results of a randomized controlled trial show that both delivery methods were equally effective at improving sleep outcomes measured by sleep diaries. They were also equally effective at reducing self-reported sleep latency and wake-after-sleep onset. They also increased total sleep time and sleep efficiency.
Moreover, there were no differences between the two delivery methods in patients’ perception of therapeutic warmth or confidence in the therapist’s skills.
Cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia rated just as high by patients
“”The most surprising findings in the study were that, contrary to our hypotheses, participants who received CBT for insomnia via telemedicine rated therapist alliance similarly to participants who received face-to-face CBT for insomnia,” said principal investigator J. Todd Arnedt of the University of Michigan.
“In addition, ratings of satisfaction with treatment were equivalent between face-to-face and telemedicine participants. Relative to other remote modalities, telemedicine may offer a unique blend of convenience for the patient while preserving fidelity of the face-to-face interaction.”
Insomnia involves difficulty falling asleep or staying asleep, or regularly waking up earlier than desired, despite allowing enough time in bed for sleep. Daytime symptoms associated with insomnia include fatigue or sleepiness; feeling dissatisfied with sleep; having trouble concentrating; feeling depressed, anxious or irritable; and having low motivation or energy.
The most effective treatment for chronic insomnia is cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia (CBTI, sometimes also known as CBT-I). It combines behavioral strategies, such as setting a consistent sleep schedule and getting out of bed when struggling with sleep, with cognitive strategies, such as replacing fears about sleeplessness with more helpful expectations. Experts customize CBTI recommendations to address each patient’s individual needs and symptoms.
CBTI and chronic insomnia
The analysis comparing sleep and daytime functioning variables included 47 adults with chronic insomnia, including 33 women. The analysis of therapeutic alliance involved 38 adults with insomnia, including 25 women.
Participants had an average age of about 52. The researchers randomized them into six sessions of CBT-I delivered face-to-face, or via the AASM SleepTM telemedicine system. One therapist delivered CBT-I in both conditions.
“Preliminary findings from this study suggest that patients undergoing telemedicine for insomnia can feel just as close and supported by their therapist as if they were in the office,” said co-author Deirdre Conroy of the University of Michigan.
“Telemedicine could be utilized more for CBT-I to bridge the gap between supply and demand for this service.”
Related psychology news:
- A high IQ increases the probability of being liked by peers, but also decreases the probability of liking them back.
- According to a new research paper, conservatives are more decisive and more confident in their judgments than liberals are.
- TV violence involving guns (versus other forms of violence) increased from 2000 to 2018, in step with actual gun homicides.
- A typical high-speed, air-based hand dryer spreads more germs and bacteria than paper towels do.
- About 76% of Americans who have been working from home since Covid say it has improved their relationships with their co-workers.
More information on cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia:
- CBT therapy near me: this handy guide lets you search by city or ZIP code
- A behavioral therapist guide published by the Dep’t of Veterans Affairs: “A Therapist’s Guide to Brief Cognitive. Behavioral Therapy” (PDF)
- An introduction to stimulus control.
- CBT I training: would you also like to learn this skill? Check out this helpful UPenn guide.
Study: “Comparison of Therapeutic Alliance for Telemedicine vs. Face-to-Face Delivered Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia: Preliminary Results”
Authors: Deirdre A Conroy, Ann Mooney, Dari Pace, Sydney Balstad, Kelley Dubuc, Alexander Yang, and J Todd Arnedt
Published in: Sleep
Publication date: April 12, 2019
Picture: by Adrià Crehuet Cano on Unsplash